The neighbourhoods most similar to Old Colorado City are Manitou Springs and downtown Colorado Springs.
Manitou Springs, located at the base of Pikes Peak, shares a similar historic charm with Old Colorado City. It's known for its natural mineral springs, which you can sample at various public fountains dotted around the town. The main street, Manitou Avenue, is lined with art galleries, unique shops, and restaurants, all housed in well-preserved Victorian buildings. It's a very walkable area, superb for those who enjoy exploring on foot.
Couples often find Manitou Springs particularly appealing due to its relaxed pace and scenic surroundings. You can easily access attractions like the Manitou Cliff Dwellings or the Cog Railway to Pikes Peak from here. The town has a distinct, artistic feel, making it a lovely place for a romantic getaway.
Downtown Colorado Springs offers a more urban, yet still historic, experience. While larger than Old Colorado City, it boasts a revitalised core with a good selection of restaurants, breweries, and boutique shops, particularly along Tejon Street and Cascade Avenue. It's home to the Colorado Springs Pioneers Museum and offers a variety of cultural venues.
For travellers who appreciate a blend of historic architecture with modern amenities and a wider range of dining options, downtown Colorado Springs is a strong contender.